Did you ever stop to think, and forget to start again? ~Winnie the Pooh

During a very interesting event organised this week for the Carnegie Foundation by Suw Charman on the subject of Civil Society, we discussed people’s willingness or otherwise to engage in social media and the new ways of organising and influencing the world that it is making possible.

One of the participants gave the example of a friend of his who he claimed didn’t really want to think too hard about things. He was content to do his job, get paid, watch television, and sleep. I found this more than slightly patronising, although it obviously wasn’t intended as such, then suggested that perhaps people were content to live a quiet life without burning ambition because they had been trained to be such by school systems designed to produce cannon fodder for a Taylorist world of work that appears to be dying.

On the other hand in my own reaction I was reminded of one of my favourite sayings – “to rescue someone is to oppress them”. In other words, taking a decision on someone else’s behalf that they need “improved”, or that their own decisions on how to lead their lives are not as good as our decisions for them, is equally unattractive. I am very sensitive to the risks of a small group of social media zealots knowing what is good for the world whether the world likes it or not.

And yet, as will be clear from my own desire for people to think more for themselves, as expressed in my previous post, I worry that what I see as an organic, complex adaptive system – i.e. the world – needs each individual or cell to operate to their full capacity and as autonomously as possible. These thoughts are captured for me in the following section, quoted in Chomsky On Anarchism, from Wilhelm Von Humboldt;

The incapacity for freedom can only arise from a want of moral and intellectual power; to heighten this power is the only way to supply this want; but to do this presupposes the exercise of the power, and this exercise presupposes the freedom which awakens spontaneous activity. Only it is clear we cannot call it giving freedom, when bonds are relaxed which are not felt as such by him who wears them. But of no man on earth – however neglected by nature, and however degraded by circumstances – is this true of all the bonds which oppress him. Let us undo them one by one, as the feeling of freedom awakens in men’s hearts, and we shall hasten progress at every step.

6 thoughts on “Did you ever stop to think, and forget to start again? ~Winnie the Pooh”

  1. i always remember my father said to me .. today should be better than yesterday , if not , you’re not making progress . .

    Like

  2. Thanks Euan, Appreciate the post and what a great title too. I recall a conversation I had with a manager that explained to me that in his business unit, they "had to" create ways to restrict their employees from thinking, as thinking lead to variability and variability lead to inconsistent customer experience. He referred to this as a 6 Sigma approach to managing customer experience. Yes, it was a real conversation.Your post reminded me of this discussion and how there are so many challenges we have in removing the bonds that stifle thinking.

    Like

  3. very thought provoking piece, thanks Euan.Here are a couple of my provoked thoughts:If we were all free-thinking, independent-minded folk, would we need or accept the political class?For those of us who spend possibly too much time thinking, do we need others to occasionally spur us to break off from thinking and into doing?

    Like

  4. The quote reminds me of my daughter as she studied German at uni and one of her essays was on Wilhelm von Humboldt, German education system and Napoleon! That was a real man of action who thought deeply and explored options before jumping- and his wife was a great help all around. Apparently, when he left Vatican and went back to Berlin, she stayed behind for another two years and they corresponded regularly about deep issues as well as family matters.Incidentally, he not only introduced German school system (primary schools + gymnasiums) but also influenced creation of German Research universities. Guess they did not have Twitter or television to spend time on….

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s